Does an Ethernet port on the WiFi Extender actually matter?

I have had the chance to test a few dedicated WiFi extenders and have configured a few access points to work as WiFi extenders as well and yes, all had at least an Ethernet port. But why do you actually need it? Let me give you an example about a networking device that has removed any Ethernet port with the exception of the one for PoE and I am talking about ceiling-mountable wireless access points.

It does make sense up to a certain point considering that the users won’t like having cables hanging down to a client device. But can this logic be applied to the WiFi extenders as well? From an aesthetic point of view, I guess so. But, when you use a WiFi extender, it is because you either hate to have cables in your house or it’s just too costly to install new ones (retrofitting an old house), which is why these devices can receive the signal from your router and then push it forward to your clients that were either connected at a low data transfer rate or had no signal whatsoever.

rock-space-ax1800-wifi-6-extender
Rock Space AX1800 WiFi extender.

So, having an Ethernet port to connect the WiFi extender to the router makes zero sense because at that point, it’s better to use a proper access point. But there are a few other applications where it does make sense, such as connecting a client device via cable or even an Ethernet switch for multiple client devices. That is, if the WiFi extenders can actually handle such a setup.

And most don’t due to overheating, not that the other components are too under powered. There’s also another possibility that involves interlinking WiFi with (non-WiFi) powerline adapters. So, I think it would be interesting to explore some of these applications and if it actually make sense to add an Ethernet port to a WiFi Extender.

Is the port Gigabit?

Before anything else, let’s talk about the Ethernet port on the WiFi Extender. Is it Gigabit? Of course it is, you may boldly affirm, but you’d be surprised by how many things the manufacturers skimp on when they build their WiFi extenders.

rocks-space
Rock Space AC1200 WiFi extender.

Let me give you an example, the Rock Space AC1200 that I personally tested about three years ago which is pretty much the same device as the Tenda A18 and it has a Fast Ethernet port (max 100Mbps). And this is weirdly common for the more budget-friendly WiFi extenders which includes most such devices on the market, with the exception of the Netgear Orbi. The good news is that the WiFi 6 extenders seem to be better equipped and the Rock Space AX1800 does indeed have a Gigabit port at the bottom.

So, be careful with WiFi 5 extenders, because it’s very common for these devices to have Fast Ethernet ports only. The reason for that, I think, is because the manufacturer knew that a lot of WiFi extender barely get to 100Mbps, so why bother going higher than that?

Use the Ethernet port on a WiFi Extender for non-demanding devices

This ties in with the previous section because the WiFi extender is usually very bad at providing reliable Internet access to devices that run demanding applications. To understand why, it’s important to know what the WiFi extenders actually do. To keep it short, they cut your bandwidth by at least a half because while extending a certain radio band, the communication needs to be made from the router to the extender and the other way around, as well as from the WiFi extender to the client device and back.

Ethernet port on the WiFi Extender
Draytek Vigor 920RP rugged access point set as WiFi extender.

Which is why they’re actually annoyingly ineffective in a lot of cases. So, when the manufacturers have added an Ethernet port from the goodness of their hearts to the WiFi extenders, they didn’t actually expect that you’ll connect a gaming/streaming PC, expecting to see something close to full Gigabit. I mean, you’re only going to see such as performance with a cabled connection directly to the router, but I digress.

If you have an old printer that doesn’t have a WiFi adapter built-in or a PC that doesn’t require a lot of bandwidth, then this is what that Ethernet port is for. But even so, be careful about the heat management.

The dreaded heat management

If you decide to use a modern access point as a WiFi extender, you shouldn’t really worry about the heat management, because the APs are actually great at keeping the temperature in check (I should know since I tested a lot of them). But let’s be honest, you’re either going to transform an older router into a WiFi repeater or you’re going to get a dedicated device.

rock-space-ax1800-hardware
Rock Space AX1800 Teardown.

And both will struggle at keeping the temperature down, especially the latter. The dedicated WiFi extenders are relatively small and have the plug built into the case, so you connect the device directly to the wall socket. It’s a very convenient approach, but the internal PSU crammed next to the other components ensure that the device will run hot all the time. This also means that the device doesn’t last long and it can also spell doom for your WiFi performance.

That’s because these devices will have to throttle the performance, so the device doesn’t overheat or, in a worse case scenario, catch fire.
Which is why it’s wise to limit the number of wireless client devices that are connected to the WiFi adapter, as well as connecting demanding devices via Ethernet cable.

But I want to connect demanding client devices!

I am not going to say that you can’t, but you do need to buy more expensive devices. That’s because that Fast Ethernet AC1200 WiFi extender is not going to cut it. Let’s say you do use a more powerful WiFi extender, such as the Rock Space AX1800 or a converted modern AP, and you want to connect a gaming PC via Ethernet cable. Since I tested this WiFi extender, I know that it can reach the necessary speed without much trouble, but I would still be aware of other particularities that make a WiFi connection less viable (such as interference).

200mbps-enough-gaming
Source: Photo by cottonbro

The idea is that you can use a more demanding device with a powerful WiFi extender, but not so much with the older or cheaper ones. But what about an Ethernet switch for additional client devices? It can work, but again, be aware that the connection between the router and the WiFi extender is not as reliable as a cabled one. Also, more devices means more power from the chip and, when paired to the crammed design, it could result in an unfortunate amount of throttling.

What about powerline adapters?

This is an interesting approach that I am sure a lot of people want to try for themselves. You connect a powerline adapter next to the router, another next to the WiFi adapter so, instead of relying on the WiFi connection, you use powerline to extend the coverage.

netgear-plp2000-powerline
Powerline adapter system.

It’s actually pretty clever, but there are some drawbacks. First, it’s the very nature of the powerline technology because it relies on the existing circuits to move data and, if the house is old, the adapters will have to jump through multiple circuits, so you may get a very unstable speed performance. Also, be aware that a lot of powerline adapters have WiFi built into one of the units, so you don’t really need to rely on a separate device for that – some even have multiple Ethernet ports.

Connecting the WiFi extender to a router using an Ethernet cable

This is a very good approach since it removes all the disadvantages that you get when the connection is made via WiFi. No more interference and the bandwidth is no longer halved. Also, congratulations, you now have an access point. As a side note, make sure to check that the WiFi extender actually supports Ethernet backhaul because some do not.

Leave a Comment